Scalper1 News
An alternatives to a traditional government bond holding. Utilities offer steady, consistent returns and are largely immune to the business cycle. This equal weight utilities fund is biased towards low dividend risk, yet has a respectable return. The world of investing has changed much over the past five years due to the financial crises of 2008 and its subsequent recession. The realization that investing may never be the same is a growing one, particular when it comes to income. As it stands now, even if central banks are able to normalize policy, it still may be years before government bond yields normalize, and that’s under the assumption that all advanced economies will continue to grow uniformly. Recent economic reversals in newly emerged economies, particularly the “BRICS” along with the collapse in commodity prices and the astonishing overproduction of crude petroleum have all weighed on high quality assets yields. High quality government securities have been pressed to their limits. Furthermore, cross market technology, institutional trading, pension fund demands and ‘carry asset’ strategies have created much higher volatility in the once mundane government bond market. The point of the matter is that the individual investor may be saving for retirement in a completely new world. The strategy of holding long term government bonds as a portfolio cornerstone has become an ‘old world’ concept. Utilities assets may be one replacement solution for government bond holdings. There are several to choose from, and one of the top yielding in the class is the Guggenheim S&P 500 Equal Weight Utilities ETF (NYSEARCA: RYU ) . According to Guggenheim, the fund “… Seeks to replicate as closely as possible, before fees and expenses, the performance of the S&P 500 Equal Weight Index Telecommunication Services & Utilities. ..” A word about the ‘equal weight’ S&P Index: according to S&P, the equal weight S&P 500 index is an alternative version of its renowned S&P 500 market cap weighted index. In the equal weight index each S&P 500 member constitutes 20 basis points of the S&P 500 index with a quarterly rebalancing in order to prevent excessive turnover. The S&P 500 equal weight Telecommunications and Utility Index is merely a subset of the equal weight S&P 500 index. Since the fund is based on ‘equal weightings’, it seems superfluous to analyze the top ten holdings. Instead, since the objective here is dividend risk assessment it would be more useful to analyze the potential risk to regular distributions. This may be achieved by comparing a company’s payout ratio to the dividend. Since a payout ratio is defined to be the proportion of earnings paid out as dividends, the lower the payout ratio the less likely the dividend will be reduced and conversely, the higher the payout ratio, the more likely a dividend may be reduced. The fund has 34 holdings and an average dividend yield of 4.0571%. The average payout ratio is 73.62%. (This is less than the S&P 500 market cap weighted payout ratio of almost 85). Five of the holdings have payout ratios of over 100%; 21 of the 34 holdings are below the average payout ratio; 11 are above; 2 have non applicable payout ratios; 14 of the holdings are above the fund’s average yield, and 20 are below the fund’s average yield. Hence, the fund is biased towards the ability of the holding to continue to pay or increase dividends. The chart below summarizes the payout ratio (in blue) and the yield (in red). (click to enlarge) (Data from Reuters and Guggenheim) The 10 lowest payout ratios average out to 44.39% with an average yield of 3.563%. There are no Telecom Service companies in the fund with a payout ratio low enough to place it in the ten lowest of the fund. (Data from Reuters and Guggenheim) The 10 holdings with the lowest payout ratio are summarized in the table below. Company Type Price/Earnings (TTM) Price/Cash Flow Price/Book Divided Yield Payout Ratio AES Corp (NYSE: AES ) Independent Power and Renewable 9.70 3.24 2.14 3.31% 23.43% Edison International (NYSE: EIX ) Electric Utility 12.60 5.52 1.72 2.80% 33.70% PPL Corp (NYSE: PPL ) Electric Utility 10.84 6.49 2.11 4.81% 38.81% Dominion Resources (NYSE: D ) Multi-Utility 24.29 12.25 3.40 3.65% 41.43% Scana Corp (NYSE: SCG ) Multi-Utility 10.29 6.69 1.44 4.04% 43.98% Nextera Energy (NYSE: NEE ) Electric Utility 15.56 8.11 2.16 3.02% 45.61% Sempra Energy (NYSE: SRE ) Multi-Utility 17.77 9.24 2.07 2.88% 48.80% Public Service Enterprise (NYSE: PEG ) Multi-Utility 11.13 6.56 1.61 3.85% 52.13% Eversource Energy (NYSE: ES ) Electric Utility 16.76 9.80 1.50 3.46% 55.99% Exelon Corp (NYSE: EXC ) Electric Utility 11.59 4.20 1.15 3.95% 56.51% (Data from Reuters and Guggenheim) There are, as one might expect, different types of Utility Companies. Diversified Telecommunications includes entertainment, mobile, internet and voice services; Electric Utilities are, as the name implies, electricity providers although some, Duke Energy for instance, provide natural gas as well; Independent Power and Renewables generate power through renewable resources like wind and solar and also install residential and business solar systems; Multi-Utilities provide natural gas, electricity, storage facilities and pipeline delivery. (Data from Reuters and Guggenheim) For a few detailed examples: AES is global, providing services to Chile, Columbia, Argentina, Brazil, Central America, the Caribbean, Europe and Asia. AES generates renewable power from solar, wind, hydro, bio mass and landfill gas. Scana Corporation, classified by the Guggenheim fund as ‘Multi-Utility’ provides natural gas as well as fiber-optic and telecomm services. Dominion Resources distributes natural gas, electricity, natural gas storage, LNG transportation and risk management services. It also has an equity stake in a joint venture with Caiman Energy called Blue Racer , a Marcellus Shale natural gas processing company; neither are publically owned companies. NiSource Inc (NYSE: NI ) is a holding company providing services through 13 subsidiaries for gas, electric and pipeline as well as a financing service. Many of these companies also hedge or trade derivative contracts. The point being that for utility funds with only a few holdings, it’s worth examining the descriptions or company profiles of the holdings to fully understand the depth of the individual holdings. (click to enlarge) Lastly, the fund has a reasonably long history, incepted in November of 2006. Its expense ratio is reasonable at 0.40%. Its total net assets are over $112,487,000 distributed over 34 holdings with a cash reserve. The average daily volume is 186,066 shares per day and there are 1.6 million outstanding shares. It currently trades at a slight discount, $-0.08 per share to NAV. The fund has paid a total of $17.80 in quarterly dividends since inception. Hence, the fund provides a reasonable yield in today’s low yield environment, low volatility with a beta of 0.87 and reasonable liquidity. Should the global economy contract because of a readjustment in the Chinese economy, and the U.S. economy remains reasonably strong with depressed commodity prices, a utility fund such as the Guggenheim S&P 500 Equal Weight Utilities ETF would do well generating good returns with relative safety for some time to come. Disclosure: I/we have no positions in any stocks mentioned, and no plans to initiate any positions within the next 72 hours. (More…) I wrote this article myself, and it expresses my own opinions. I am not receiving compensation for it (other than from Seeking Alpha). I have no business relationship with any company whose stock is mentioned in this article. Additional disclosure: Additional disclosure: CFDs, spreadbetting and FX can result in losses exceeding your initial deposit. They are not suitable for everyone, so please ensure you understand the risks. Seek independent financial advice if necessary. Nothing in this article should be considered a personal recommendation. It does not account for your personal circumstances or appetite for risk. Scalper1 News
Scalper1 News