Tag Archives: spy

Utilities Are Not The Safe Haven You Think They Are

On a peak to trough basis, utilities have underperformed the S&P 500 and Dow Jones Industrial Average in 2015. XLU fell 56.87% and 49.66% during each of the last two bear markets. It’s not worth the extra yield to buy something with as much risk to principal as utilities stocks. In my recent article, ” The Fed Might Do Something It Hasn’t Done In 28 Years ,” I dispelled a myth concerning the labor force participation rate that’s been floating around the financial world. Today, I turn my attention to dispelling another myth: that utilities stocks are a safe-haven investment. For some strange reason, utilities have gained a reputation for being a safe-haven during turbulent times. Perhaps that was true in the distant past. But in today’s world, it couldn’t be further from the truth. As volatility picked up in recent weeks, it wouldn’t surprise me if many investors in the Seeking Alpha community dumped some money in utilities, under the assumption that a nearly 4% yield and reliable cash flows will protect you from a potential bear market. For those investors and anyone else considering parking money in Wall Street’s notorious safe haven, the chart below might make you cringe. (click to enlarge) As you can see on the monthly chart, during each of the past two bear markets, the Utilities Select Sector SPDR Fund (NYSEARCA: XLU ), an ETF that serves as a proxy for the utilities sector, was absolutely destroyed. During the 2000 to 2002 bear market, XLU declined 56.87%. That decline was worse than the S&P 500’s (NYSEARCA: SPY ) 50.51% drop and worse than the Dow Jones Industrial Average’s (NYSEARCA: DIA ) 38.75% fall. Although XLU managed to outperform the S&P 500 and the Dow during the 2007 to 2009 bear market, it still fell 49.66% peak to trough. I can’t imagine any investor thinking a 50% drop would qualify something as a safe haven, even if that security pays a couple of percentage points more in dividends than do funds tracking the major market averages. What’s happened so far in 2015? Once again, XLU is underperforming the Dow and the S&P 500. The peak to trough declines for XLU are 17.66%, while the Dow pulled back 16.24% and the S&P 500 fell 12.54%. Unlike a bond, which matures at par, there is no contractual obligation ensuring XLU will ever return to the level at which you bought it. I realize that in today’s low interest rate environment, investors who are desperate for income may be tempted to buy utilities for the 3.79% SEC yield XLU currently sports. I’d rather make 0% in a deposit account or 3%+ in any number of individual corporate bonds, than assume the substantial risk to principal that utilities have shown in recent bear markets. Yes, I realize that during smaller bull market corrections, utilities have shown themselves to be outperformers. But who needs “safe havens” in bull markets? It’s the bear market safe havens that are valuable. And utilities, in this millennium, have been anything but a bear market safe haven. Just because everyone repeats something over and over, doesn’t mean that thing is necessarily true. An investment with substantial risk to your principal is not a safe haven, no matter how many pundits claim it is. Disclosure: I am/we are long SPY. (More…) I wrote this article myself, and it expresses my own opinions. I am not receiving compensation for it (other than from Seeking Alpha). I have no business relationship with any company whose stock is mentioned in this article.

Why To Stay The Course In This New Age Of Volatility

Stocks tumbled again last week, as investors digested further evidence of slowing growth in China and numerous, somewhat conflicting, statements from various Federal Reserve (Fed) officials. Investors today find themselves in a bind of sorts, caught between two somewhat contradictory risks: an emerging market-induced slowdown in the global economy and the prospect of an upcoming interest rate hike by the Fed. So, it’s understandable that many are tempted to head for the doors and abandon stocks and other risky assets. But rather than exit the markets, investors should consider staying the course and seek potential opportunities along the way as we enter the Fall season, while recognizing that more volatility could be ahead. As I write in my new commentary, ” Time to Take Stock – and Advantage of Pockets of Value ,” at BlackRock, we still favor a portfolio tilted toward equities, select credit, tax-exempt bonds and inflation protection through Treasury Inflation Protected Securities ( OTC:TIPS ) rather than physical commodities. In addition, we view the recent sell-off as an opportunity to take advantage of some pockets of value that have emerged , as well as assets that may be well positioned for today’s “Fed hike, but still low-growth environment.” Here’s a look at some of these market segments: Market Segments to Consider 1. Stocks in International Developed Markets, Particularly in Europe European stocks remain attractively priced and the eurozone economy is improving, as demonstrated by data accessible via Bloomberg. Last week, such data revealed that euro area unemployment fell to the lowest level in three years. In addition, given stubbornly low inflation and investor concerns over global growth, there’s also the prospect for an extension of Europe’s current quantitative easing program, as many in the media speculated last week. 2. Large-Cap, Cyclical Stocks in the U.S. In the U.S., I believe large-cap, cyclical-oriented companies look to be in a good position to withstand the start of the Fed’s tightening cycle. The U.S. economic outlook is less than ideal, but U.S. economic data in recent weeks still suggest a decent second half to the year . 3. Credit Within Fixed Income Despite recent equity market volatility, high yield has stabilized over the past week and yields remain attractive, according to data accessible via Bloomberg. Investment-grade credit is also looking cheap, the data show, although investors may want to hold off until later this Fall, given pending supply. 4. Tax-Exempt Bonds Finally, tax-exempt bonds are offering compelling yields relative to taxable instruments of the same maturity, based on my analysis of the Bloomberg data. Despite the recent rise in volatility, municipals have held up relatively well. To be sure, there are areas of the market that I remain cautious of, including U.S. Treasuries and commodities. On the former, with inflation expectations still near recent lows, investors may want to get duration through TIPS rather than through traditional Treasuries. Commodities, meanwhile, have struggled all year and should continue to be pressured by sluggish growth, oversupply and the potential for a Fed-induced strengthening of the dollar. Investors also should prepare for more bumps in the road. Though the recent correction has returned some value to the markets , I expect volatility to remain elevated until either global growth stabilizes and/or investors get some clarity from the Fed. This post originally appeared on the BlackRock Blog.