Tag Archives: simple-investment-ideas

NRG Energy – Adding Value With A Business Restructuring

Summary NRG Energy’s dream of building one of the first integrated fossil fuel and clean energy businesses will go unfulfilled. NRG Energy plans to spit off its clean energy business in a few months time, forming what will be known as “GreenCo.”. While the fossil fuel and clean energy business have many synergies, a separation of these two businesses is likely more viable in the current investment atmosphere. NRG Energy’s clean energy business will have to compete with ultra-competitive solar companies as a standalone company, which could prove to be a large obstacle. Over the past few years, NRG Energy (NYSE: NRG ) has stood out in its attempt to become the first major integrated fossil fuel and renewable energy company. While the company has successfully integrated these two businesses to some extent, there have been many obstacles that have limited NRG Energy’s overall success in this endeavor. There are many aspects of the distributed solar business, in particular, that do not mix well with the traditional fossil fuel power business. While these two businesses are not at odds in theory, the relatively unproven distributed solar business has made investors wary. As such, the company decided to split off its clean energy business into what will be known as “GreenCo.” Here is a chart explaining why NRG Energy is planning to split off its clean energy business. (click to enlarge) Source: NRG Energy Integration Problems NRG Energy’s plan to integrate a large clean energy business was not flawed in theory. NRG Energy could use the comparatively vast resources from its fossil fuel business to help catalyze its burgeoning clean energy business. This would put the company at a financial advantage against pure play clean energy companies like Vivint Solar (NYSE: VSLR ). However, the downsides associated with such integration seem to be outweighing the benefits. One of the main problems with this strategy is that fossil fuel and clean energy investors are generally of different mindsets. Fossil fuel investors are usually more interested in more stable businesses, whereas clean energy investors are more interested in growth. While NRG Energy’s clean energy business has enormous growth potential, many fossil fuel investors are likely off-put by the segment’s more risky nature. On the flip side, many clean energy investors are likely put-off by NRG Energy’s relatively low growth fossil fuel business. While there are indeed many investors that find the combination of businesses attractive, it seems as if separating these two businesses would attract more investors on balance. In addition, both the fossil fuel and clean energy businesses require a huge amount of attention. Pure-play distributed solar companies like SolarCity (NASDAQ: SCTY ) already have their hands full just managing their specific businesses. In NRG Energy’s case, distributed solar is just one segment in a larger business portfolio. It is unlikely that the company would be able to invest the optimal amount of time and energy into all of its businesses. While many synergies certainly do exist in NRG Energy’s fossil fuel and clean energy businesses, it seems as though separating the businesses would unlock more value due to the combination of current investor sentiment and limited attention/resources. Pure-Play Approach NRG Energy’s pure-play approach will likely attract more investors over the long-run. However, this also means that its renewable spin-off will be competing against the likes of SolarCity, Vivint Solar, etc, with much less assistance. The big financial advantage of NRG Energy’s clean energy businesses will mostly disappear once the company is spun-off from its fossil fuels business(NRG Energy is planning to give the GreenCo a financial limit of $125M in 2016). With that being said, NRG Energy’s clean energy business is still doing relatively well, and will likely succeed even without the help of the company’s main business. NRG Energy believes that there is ~$1B that can be unlocked by spinning off its clean energy business, which could very well be true given the benefits of separation. As investors will likely favor this strategy, as was mentioned before, NRG Energy is likely going down the correct path. Shareholders should benefit from the company’s planned pure-play approach, especially given the increasing complexities of the clean energy business. While CEO David Crane’s integrated energy plan was sound in principle, it may have been too early to implement this as investors have not fully committed to the idea. Obstacles While there are definitely many positives associated with a clean energy spin-off, the company could find it difficult to adjust as a pure play. Also, the company may have more trouble financing its operations as was mentioned before. Whereas the NRG Energy’s clean energy business currently has an advantage in financing due to its relationship with NRG Energy’s fossil fuel business, this will no longer be the case after the spin-off occurs. Competing against well-established companies like SolarCity and Vivint Solar could prove to be more difficult than expected. Regardless, the distributed solar market in particular is still incredibly underpenetrated, which means that NRG Energy’s GreenCo has great growth opportunities. Conclusion While NRG Energy’s grand plan to integrate massive fossil fuel and clean energy businesses has been derailed, the company is still undervalued at a market capitalization of $5.1B . Given that most of the company’s growth potential lies in its clean energy segment, NRG Energy may no longer be undervalued after it splits off its clean energy business. In theory, the synergies of NRG Energy’s fossil fuel and clean energy business should have outweighed the negatives of such integration. With that being said, investors are still largely uncomfortable with this idea, thus making the planned spin-off a smart decision for shareholders.

NRG Energy – Leading The Green Transition

Summary While NRG Energy’s conventional fossil fuel business continues to underperform, the company’s renewable business is more promising than ever. NRG Energy’s distributed solar business is growing at a rapid pace and should be a huge growth engine for the company moving forward. NRG Energy’s diversified energy portfolio should provide the company with unique advantages. The turbulent energy commodities market will likely continue to pose challenges for NRG Energy in the near-term. NRG Energy (NYSE: NRG ) clearly believes in the potential of clean energy as it has put a large emphasis on solar PV. Despite this, the majority of the company’s business is still based on conventional generation(i.e. fossil fuels), which commands ~70% of the company’s capital allocation. NRG Energy largely disappointed during its Q2 due to the underperformance in its conventional generation business, which is not so surprising given the turmoil in the energy markets. Despite the fact that the company missed on both EPS and revenue, which came in at $0.06 and $3.4B respectively, the company still has much to look forward to. Renewables currently receives ~30% of NRG Energy’s capital allocation, which is a figure that is bound to skyrocket moving forward. Although conventional generation still makes up for most of NRG Energy’s business, the company is making a rapid and smart transition to solar PV. During the Q2 earnings call, the company gave much more insight into how important it thinks solar will become. In fact, CEO David Crane even stated that “The future is going to be increasingly solar-powered and increasingly distributed.” This optimism surrounding solar PV will likely propel NRG Energy past its competitors moving forward. Ramping Up Distributed Solar PV Operations NRG Energy has put a heavy emphasis on developing its distributed solar PV business. As this is perhaps the most promising solar PV segment in the U.S., NRG Energy is definitely on the right path. During Q2, the company’s bookings nearly doubled on a YOY basis, recording 90% higher bookings. This translates into 19,410 NRG Home Solar customers as of Q2, which shows that the company is clearly building a respectable distributed solar infrastructure. Even more impressive, the company has maintained ~20% QOQ since the end of 2014. Such a promising distributed solar business places NRG Energy among the top distributed solar providers. NRG Energy still has enormous growth ahead of it as the company has barely scratched the surface of the home solar market. As the company is one of the first conventional energy companies to make a large-scale transition to solar, it has a meaningful first mover’s advantage. Not surprisingly, NRG Energy is rapidly climbing the ranks of top rooftop solar providers, even challenging the likes of Vivint Solar (NYSE: VSLR ) and Sunrun (NASDAQ: RUN ). Given that NRG Energy also has the advantage of maintaining a conventional energy business that could provide base-load generation for intermittent renewable energy sources, the company has an advantage over pure-play rooftop solar companies. Diversified Business While NRG Energy is putting a clear focus on distributed solar PV, the company is nonetheless diversified across the energy sector. This means that no matter how the future turns out, NRG Energy should be well-prepared. The company has assets ranging from wind and solar all the way to oil and gas, making it one of the most diversified energy companies in existence. As was previously stated, having both renewables and fossil fuels assets is advantageous in that fossil fuels can provide renewables with base-load generation. As renewables like wind and solar still do not have a cost-effective means of storing energy, fossil fuel assets certainly come in handy. NRG Energy is an extremely diversified energy company, with assets in nearly all the major energy markets. (click to enlarge) Source: NRG Energy Obstacles NRG Energy has all the tools to become a powerhouse in the renewable arena. While NRG Energy’s renewable prospects are looking bright, the company’s conventional business will likely continue to face some volatility and difficulties in the near-term. Given the instability in the energy markets, NRG Energy will likely continue to face difficulties moving forward. The company has seen its valuation decrease by approximately 50% over the past year alone. In the long-run however, NRG Energy is well-positioned to outperform the market. The company will also face increasingly stiff competition from the distributed solar pure plays, mainly from standout SolarCity (NASDAQ: SCTY ). While NRG Energy is indeed has an early mover’s advantage in the distributed solar industry, SolarCity is already building an unparalleled brand presence. Given that brand presence in this arena is much more important than many had expected, NRG Energy will have to make its own imprint on the market soon or risk losing market share. Given NRG Energy’s vast resources and growing infrastructure, the company is more than capable of doing this. Conclusion NRG Energy has much more room to grow at a valuation of $5.9B . While the challenging commodity market will likely continue to plague NRG Energy in the near-term, the company is making all the right moves to secure a dominant role in the long-term future. NRG Energy’s home solar business will likely push the company to greater heights, especially given how fast the distributed solar industry is growing. As the company is at the forefront of the current energy transition, it will likely reap enormous rewards as a result. Despite NRG Energy’s underperformance over the last year, the company should outperform expectations in the years to come. Disclosure: I am/we are long SCTY. (More…) I wrote this article myself, and it expresses my own opinions. I am not receiving compensation for it (other than from Seeking Alpha). I have no business relationship with any company whose stock is mentioned in this article.

NRG Energy Increases Its Solar Ambitions

Summary NRG Energy is jumping into community solar, making it one of the first companies to enter into this promising market. NRG Energy holds many unique advantages in the community solar segment, making it highly competitive against even the likes of SolarCity. The company’s growing distributed solar operations comes with many risks, most notable in the form of long-term unknowns. The community solar concept is rapidly gaining steam, with some leading solar companies jumping into this space over the past few months. Given that community solar covers the renters’ market, which consists of 108 million individuals in the U.S. alone, its sudden emergence is not so surprising. Financing in the solar industry has finally reached a stage where community solar is not only feasible, but attractive for solar companies. While there are many more complexities involved in this solar market compared to the residential or utility-scale solar markets, it should still see explosive growth in the near term. NRG Energy (NYSE: NRG ) has been the latest company to enter into the community solar market, which is not surprising given its ambitions in distributed solar. The company recently launched a 1 MW project (connected to 200 homes), which will serve as a pilot to more community solar projects in the future. With 100 MW of shared community solar projects already in its pipeline, NRG Energy clearly has big community solar ambitions. This marks the first time that NRG Energy has been able to penetrate a major solar market so early on, which should add more upside to the company’s already undervalued stock. First Mover’s Advantage The community solar market has just recently opened up, which means that NRG Energy has a huge opportunity to cement itself early on as a dominant presence. Given the immense size of the U.S. renters’ market alone, the company should be able to experience some serious growth in this arena. While the current community solar market is nearly nonexistent, this market is expected to grow at ~60% per annum until 2020. This would mean that the community solar segment should grow approximately twice as fast as the general industry during this time period. While dominating the community solar segment will certainly not be easy for NRG Energy, the company has all the tools to do so. With the operational capabilities and expertise of its NRG Home and NRG Renew business segments, the company could even compete with the likes of SolarCity (NASDAQ: SCTY ) on this front. In fact, NRG Energy’s 100 MW community solar pipeline is equivalent to that of SolarCity’s . Given that SolarCity was the first company to make a truly impactful entrance into community solar, this shows how ambitious and forward-looking NRG Energy is. GTM Research predicts that community solar will be a half-GW market (annual) by 2020. (click to enlarge) Source: GTM Research Unique Advantages NRG Energy has some major advantages over its competitors on the community solar, and more generally, distributed solar front. First, the company already has a huge customer base off of which to leverage for its distributed/community solar business. The company also has stronger relationships with electricity companies compared to its solar pure play peers, which should allow it to expand its community solar segment more rapidly. Given that cooperation with utilities will likely prove key to dominating the community solar segment, NRG Energy definitely has an edge on this front. With NRG Energy’s enormous distributed solar ambitions, it is easy to forget that the company is one of the largest fossil fuel power companies in the world. In fact, the company has a whopping ~47 GW of operational assets, which would also give the company a financing edge over its pure play solar competitors. As such, NRG Energy will almost certainly be one of the front-runners in the highly promising community solar segment. While NRG Energy’s pure play solar competitors may be more well versed in the solar arena, NRG Energy’s own unique advantages more than make up for this. Obstacles The community solar segment is still basically unexplored, which means that first movers like NRG Energy are taking on more risk. Despite the sudden surge of competitors in this arena, the community solar business model is still new. As NRG Energy is planning to make the community solar segment a sizable portion of its business down the road, the company will likely funnel a lot of its resources into this arena. Given the unknowns associated with community solar, entering into this segment is relatively risky. More generally, there are also many long-term questions about the solar leasing model used by NRG Energy. How the long-term plays out for solar leases is incredibly important for the company as it is making a huge transition to renewables, and is planning to make distributed solar one of its focal points. Regardless of such unknowns, the potential rewards of involving itself in this solar segment far outweigh the risks. NRG Energy’s transition from a fossil fuel-centric power company to one more focused around renewables should prove to be extremely smart on balance. Conclusion NRG Energy has faced a yearlong downturn, which can largely be attributed to the instability experienced by the fossil fuels industry during this time. Although many investors still view NRG Energy as part of the fossil fuels sector, the majority of the company’s long-term prospects lie in its growing renewables sector, namely solar. Given the sheer potential of its distributed solar business alone, NRG Energy is undervalued at a market valuation of $7.2B . NRG Energy is slated to be one of SolarCity’s largest competitors, which speaks to the potential that NRG Energy’s solar segment holds. The company’s entrance into community solar just reinforces its place within the future energy landscape. Disclosure: I am/we are long SCTY. (More…) I wrote this article myself, and it expresses my own opinions. I am not receiving compensation for it (other than from Seeking Alpha). I have no business relationship with any company whose stock is mentioned in this article.