Scalper1 News
Summary Southwestern electric utility PNM Resources reported yet another earnings beat in Q3 in the face of underwhelming revenue numbers as it benefited from a hot summer and cheap energy. The company reported continued weak demand in its service area in response to a shifting energy landscape that is increasingly focused on renewables. Its strategy for achieving future earnings growth by investing in its transmission and Texas operations is compelling based on the constraints faced by the region’s renewable generators. There is a good likelihood that the company’s earnings next year will be hurt by El Nino and investors are advised to wait for a better buying opportunity. Southwestern electric utility PNM Resources (NYSE: PNM ) reported yet another earnings beat on underwhelming revenues in Q3 last month as warm late summer temperatures in its service area pushed demand higher. This marked the third such combination of strong earnings amidst disappointing revenues this year, demonstrating the unique position that energy utilities are finding themselves in as energy prices are pushing for new lows. The company’s share price has moved solidly higher in response, most recently setting a 6-month high. Last June, I wrote an article on the company that highlighted the risks of slowing economic growth in its Texas and New Mexico service areas, concluding that the shares were attractively undervalued but not enough so to merit initiating a long position. While the prospect of weakening Southwestern economies in the face of low energy prices remains a concern, PNM Resources’ management discussed an important strategic realignment during the Q3 earnings call that will have important implications for earnings over the next several years. In the short term, meanwhile, the weather could provide the company with a new headwind by reducing demand for electricity in its service area. Q3 earnings report PNM Resources reported Q3 revenue of $417.4 million, up by 0.8% YoY but missing the consensus analyst estimate by $36.1 million. The annual increase was primarily the result of warm late summer temperatures in the company’s New Mexico and Texas service areas, which reported a combined 14% increase to cooling degree-days YoY and a 6% increase compared to the long-term average. Rate relief from renewables (reported by subsidiary PNM ) and transmission (reported by subsidiary TNMP ) also supported the revenue number. This result was partially offset, however, by the presence of a reduced load in PNM’s service area and generation facility outages over the course of the quarter. The number of customers increased by 0.8%, indicating that cheap energy has yet to result in a severe slowdown to the area economies. The company’s cost of revenue number fell to $124.3 million from $132.5 million YoY despite the improved revenue result due to the presence of sharply lower energy prices compared to a year ago. This allowed operating income to improve to $121.5 million from $116.8 million a year ago. Likewise, consolidated net income rose to $61 million from $55.7 million YoY, resulting in a diluted EPS result of $0.76 compared to $0.69 in the same quarter of 2014. PNM continued to be the primary contributor to consolidated earnings, and the subsidiary reported an increase to diluted EPS from $0.56 to $0.61 YoY. TNMP also increased, however, from $0.15 to $0.17 over the same period. In both cases, PNM Resources attributed the majority of the earnings increases to the presence of warm temperature during the quarter compared to the previous year, although lower expenses also contributed. Finally, the company increased its quarterly dividend by 8% to $0.20, resulting in a 2.8% forward yield. Outlook The company’s management narrowed its FY 2015 EPS guidance range from $1.50-$1.62 to $1.56-$1.61 on the basis of its consecutive earnings beats in the year. The midpoint of the new range, $1.58, is very close to the analyst consensus EPS estimate for FY 2015 of $1.59, the latter of which has increased from $1.56 over the last 90 days due to the hot summer temperatures in the company’s service area. Either result would result in YoY earnings growth of 7-8%, well within the company’s target of 7-9% through 2019. A shifting energy landscape in the U.S. has threatened in the past to derail the ability of PNM Resources to meet this targeted growth. Federal regulations on greenhouse gas emissions from power plants have caused the company to begin to phase out many of its coal-fired facilities. While the presence of cheap natural gas in the U.S. has caused many of its peers to replace its coal-fired units with gas-fired units, the abundance of solar and, to a lesser extent, wind in its service area has prompted PNM Resources to invest in renewable electricity capacity. With the exception of hydropower, however, renewables are intermittent in the sense that the capacity is not always achieving a high load when demand is also high. Furthermore, the cost of rooftop solar PV has finally fallen to the point that it is competitive on a subsidized basis with fossil fuels in sun-drenched areas such as the U.S. Southwest, causing many residential and commercial customers to become independent generators themselves rather than just consumers. Many utilities are reporting lower electricity sales volumes despite customer growth. PNM Resources has been no exception to this trend, with its subsidiary PNM reporting a YoY sales reduction of 1.7% in Q3 despite the presence of hotter temperatures on the same basis. While TNMP did report higher sales, the company expects PNM to report flat-to-negative growth which, given its outsized contribution to consolidated earnings, is important. Management’s response to this changing landscape has been to shift its planned future capex away from new generating capacity, which is no longer as essential (and therefore less likely to be part of a compelling rate case increase argument), in favor of new transmission capacity. Contrary to conventional wisdom, new solar and wind capacity in the Southwest can only be sited in limited areas due to constraints such as ecological protection, resource availability, and proximity to high-demand areas. This latter in particular is a major constraint since renewables built away from high-demand areas must be connected via lengthy transmission lines. The recently-announced Clean Power Plan, which requires utilities to reduce the carbon intensity (greenhouse gas emissions per kWh of electricity generated) of their power facility fleets over the next decade, provides a strong incentive to replace existing fossil fuel units that are located near population centers with renewable units that can be several hundred miles away, further raising demand for transmission capacity. PNM Resources stated in its Q3 earnings call that it has already signed 400 MW of transmission agreements that will send electricity generated at wind farms in New Mexico to California, which has very ambitious renewable electricity targets. The company’s transmission lines have an impressive allowed ROE of 10% and it has established a goal of increasing its transmission rate base by 53% between 2016 and 2019; by comparison, the company expects to increase its PNM retail rate base by only 4% over the same period. While ambitious, I believe that the former target is very likely to be met given the increased demand for transmission capacity that will result from the Clean Power Plan. This will more than offset a lack of retail growth, allowing PNM Resources to achieve steady earnings growth over the next several years despite reduced retail sales. While the company’s long-term outlook is attractive, its short-term outlook has weakened over the last six months as one of the strongest El Nino events on record has appeared over the U.S. Past El Ninos have caused the northern half of the country to experience warmer-than-usual winters even as the southern half experiences more cold than normal. While this winter appears set to continue this trend, PNM Resources doesn’t receive much benefit from cold winters, having sold its natural gas subsidiary utility several years ago. As an electric utility, it is very sensitive to summer temperatures, however, given the heavy reliance on air conditioning in its service areas. Texas and New Mexico are expected to experience fewer cooling degree-days in Q2, with colder-than-normal conditions lasting through June. Q2 is historically one of the company’s strongest quarters from an earnings perspective, only being surpassed by Q3 in terms of diluted EPS and often equaling the combined EPS of Q4 and Q1. A cold early summer in the company’s service areas is likely to have a sizeable impact on its earnings as a result. While PNM Resources has released a rather broad EPS guidance range for FY 2016, allowing some flexibility as temperature data comes in, the consensus analyst estimate of $1.65 has not changed over the last 90 days and is significantly higher than the lower end of the company’s range. Based on a share price at the time of writing of $28.84, the company’s shares are trading at a forward P/E ratio of 17.5x, in the top half of their historical range. If the company’s bottom guidance value of $1.50 is achieved, on the other hand, which the current weather forecast suggests is very possible, then the company’s shares are trading at the still-higher valuation of 19.2x. The company’s share valuation has tended to be quite responsive to weather conditions in the past despite their historical nature, suggesting that the share price will decline in the first half of next year if El Nino’s impact on the service area is similar to its historical impacts. Conclusion PNM Resources continued its recent streak of beating on earnings despite missing on revenues in Q3 as hot temperatures and continued customer growth more than offset lower retail sales volumes. The company’s management recently outlined its strategy to prevent falling demand in the service area of its primary subsidiary PNM by focusing instead on TNMP, where demand remains strong, and its transmission operations. I believe that this latter focus in particular will allow the company to secure several years’ worth of earnings growth since the Southwest’s focus on renewable electricity will encounter siting issues, thereby increasing demand for transmission capacity and delivery agreements. While its path forward looks secure, the market appears to be underestimating the impact that this year’s strong El Nino event will have on the number of cooling degree-days in the company’s service areas in Q2 of next year. Shares of PNM Resources are overvalued if El Nino’s past weather impacts in the Southwest occur again during the current event. Based on this, then, I encourage investors to wait for its share price to fall below $24, or 16x the lower end of management’s FY 2016 guidance, before initiating a long position. A compelling earnings growth case should not prevent investors from being in an even stronger buying position in the first half of next year. Scalper1 News
Scalper1 News