Scalper1 News
Summary The stock continued to decline after Q3. Equity investment write-down doesn’t reflect the investment’s true value. Results from core operations improved from last year. The market continues to be bearish about CenterPoint Energy (NYSE: CNP ). Given the company’s performance in 2015, it would seem that investors are doubting the stability of the utility company. After falling 20% from $23.43 at the beginning of the year to $18.68 before Q3 earnings, shares have since dropped another 8% to $17.10. Do the fundamentals support this rapid decline? Revenue continued to fall. Following Q2’s 19% drop, Q3 revenue decreased by 10% ($1.8 billion to $1.6 billion) as well, primarily as the result of lowering natural gas prices. However, this was offset by the drop in natural gas expense, which decreased from $702 million to $527 million. Due to various cost reductions, the company was able to decrease its operating expense from $493 million to $479 million. This impact may seem small, but this allowed the company to increase its operating income by 14% when compared to Q3 2014. This rise in operating profit is the first time the company achieved growth in 2015. Q1 and Q2 operating profit decreased by 13% quarter on quarter, and Q3 operating profit was flat. Isn’t this evidence that the company is improving? What are investors worried about? Possible Concern One thing that could trouble investors is the loss from equity investment ($794 million), which is the biggest reason that the company delivered a $900 million loss before taxes. The equity investment consisted solely of Enable Midstream (NYSE: ENBL ), a stock that I’ve talked about before. You can read my previous articles ( here and here ) to learn more about the company. Enable Midstream Partners is a midstream company that is suffering from industry headwinds. However, the company continues to deliver good cash flows due to its fee-based contracts. Furthermore, it is well capitalized with a good interest rate coverage ratio. Enable’s transported volume continued to grow in Q3, offsetting declining prices that negatively impacted product sales. Going forward, I believe Enable will come out on top even if natural gas prices don’t improve. What does all of this mean? I believe that the write-off of equity investment is not representative of Enable Midstream Partners’ true value. Core Operation Remains Stable Enough about Enable, what about CenterPoint’s existing operation? In my last article , I talked about the company’s stability. The Electric segment is not directly affected by commodity movements since it is not involved in power generation activities. The Natural Gas Distribution segment does have some exposure to commodity movements due to a time lag between purchases and deliveries, but the company actively uses derivatives to hedge any uncertainty. So overall, I would expect profit to be stable over the long term. CenterPoint’s stability is once again evident in Q3. Every single segment improved quarter on quarter. Operating income for the Electric segment rose 5%, Natural Gas Distribution’s operating income recovered from last year’s volatility, improving from a loss of -$8 million to a gain of $11 million, and Energy Services’ operating income increased by 17%. Takeaway I believe there’s nothing in the third quarter that was particularly alarming. The company continued to deliver stable profits amid a volatile commodity environment. Unfortunately, investors have been focusing on the wrong things. In particular, the Enable Midstream fear is overblown. Results from core operations should continue to improve, and that is what will really support the company as a whole. Scalper1 News
Scalper1 News